Posted May 2, 200024 yr comment_279 Dampening oil added to strut housing between cartridge and housing: I recently had to change the shocks in my Z, and the previous owner had changed the shocks about 3-5 years before, and he had not put any oil in the shaft the strut cartridge had gone in. The Cartridge over time had fused to the strut most likely do to excessive heat, and a lack of lubrication. As a result, this made this out to be a very unpleasant experience for me after being in there for a while the cartridge was stuck in the shaft to where it was VERY VERY difficult to come out. In fact one of the four never came out.. even after the strut had been heated with a torch (which was necessary on the others to remove them) it never came out... I was really stuck because the original strut was now damaged in trying to remove this cartridge, and where was I going to get another one when I was getting this work done with a friend, out of town, on the weekend?? I sooooooo lucked out that the Nissan dealer had an original brand new strut tower that you could no longer order sitting on the shelf because it was ordered 5 years before, and was never picked up. This was the original style with a non cartridge style shock already in it, but since I was using the same Tokico shock on the other 4, just a cartridge version it didn't matter.. I can just put in a cartridge style in there next time it needs to be changed. In short.. I really recommend lubeing the strut cartridges >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Original Message <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< On 5/1/00, 6:31:15 PM, Mike Gholson <mtg@mgdesign.net> wrote regarding RE: <240z-club> Rear Struts: > -- Group Message from Mike Gholson <mtg@mgdesign.net> -- > It is my understanding that you shouldn't need to add any > oil with MODERN strut cartridges. > The manual recommends it because the older struts depended > on the oil for heat dissipation and lubrication of the shaft. > Again, this is MY understanding. I could be totally off. > But, I didn't add any oil to my new Tokico Illumina's because > of this advice. > [m] > > -----Original Message----- > > From: Panos A. Rontos [maimailto:Prontos@gte.net] > > Sent: Saturday, April 29, 2000 11:02 AM > > To: 240z internet club > > Subject: <240z-club> Rear Struts > > > > > > -- Group Message from "Panos A. Rontos" <prontos@gte.net> -- > > > > I know that this has been covered; however, my computer has > > gone through at > > least one rebuild since then and I have lost the message. The Datsun > > service manual states I should pour 400cc of geniune Nissan > > strut oil or > > equalivant into the case for cooling. Any suggestions as to > > what to use? > -------------------------------------------------------------- Link to comment https://www.classiczcars.com/forums/topic/123-strut-cartridge-replacement-dampening-oil/ Share on other sites More sharing options...
May 2, 200024 yr Author comment_280 -- Group Message from "Pete Paraska" <pparaska@tidalwave.net> --Mike Gholson <mtg@mgdesign.net> wrote:>Is this really a concern if you purchase a high-end strut>cartridge? I figure that their engineering methods would>lessen this possiblity.Strut cartridges and shocks convert mechanical energy to heat.The amount of heat generated is proportional to the damping.Damping is the mechanical energy involved and has to do withthe force (related to the Illumina's setting), velocity and translation of the two ends of the "damper".I don't have handy any numbers on what the amount or rate of conversion of this heat is for different driving conditions,but it's not inconsequential. I wouldn't bet that air aloneis enough to convect the heat away quick enough from the strutcartridge body to the strut tube during spirited driving. Theamount of connection between the strut tube and cartridge isminimal for conduction heat transfer.Any racers here want to chime in?--------------------------------------------------------------©The Internet 240z-Club - Our Web Site: http://www.240z.org Our Bulletin Board: http://www.240z.org/forums.htm Send your Email messages to: mailto:240z-club@peak.org-------------------------------------------------------------- Link to comment https://www.classiczcars.com/forums/topic/123-strut-cartridge-replacement-dampening-oil/#findComment-280 Share on other sites More sharing options...
May 2, 200024 yr Author comment_281 > Any racers here want to chime in?OK, chiming in...> I wouldn't bet that air alone> is enough to convect the heat away quick enough from the strut> cartridge body to the strut tube during spirited driving. The> amount of connection between the strut tube and cartridge is> minimal for conduction heat transfer.FYI... my Tokico Illuminas are in the struts dry. Purely a maintenance,cleanliness issue.Shocks heating up and loosing effectiveness is not really an issue in autoxbecause you have time between runs for everything to cool down. Tireoverheating will occur way before you have any issues with the shocks. Atthe MSA autox last Saturday I did 6 back-to-back 46 second runs and greasytires ended my fun, not the shocks getting hot. Also, I've run 20 and 30minute track sessions at Buttonwillow and WSR and hot shocks were never aconcern.But, Peter is right from a theoretical point of view and if I was building arally 240Z I would definately do everything I could to cool the shocks.----------John Coffeyjohncof@veriomail.com Link to comment https://www.classiczcars.com/forums/topic/123-strut-cartridge-replacement-dampening-oil/#findComment-281 Share on other sites More sharing options...
May 2, 200024 yr Author comment_282 -- Group Message from Rob Harville <RobH@Insynq.com> --I would think shock overheating would be much more of an issue in off-roadracing like the Baja series. They have MUCH more suspension travel and athigh speeds. The tire heating isn't as much of an issue because of theloose "track" surface. This is why they run remote-reservoir shocks with avery high oil capacity w/ coolers on the reservoirs. I've never heard ofthis being an issue with NASCAR, CART or INDY. Even with autox, there justisn't enough constant full-travel articulation. Link to comment https://www.classiczcars.com/forums/topic/123-strut-cartridge-replacement-dampening-oil/#findComment-282 Share on other sites More sharing options...
May 2, 200024 yr Author comment_283 > How about every-day drivers? Or, weekend excursions along> the coastal highways?If I can't heat these things up at an autox or a track like Buttonwillowthen I don't think a street driver can do it, unless they are driving fastover the pot-holed roads of Detroit. You would need a lot of low frequency,large travel or high frequency, short travel inputs to start generatingheat. You really aren't much of that on the street unless the road arereally bumpy. Also, have you driven Pacific Coast Highway lately? You'llspend most of your time going < 25mph behind a Mini-Winnie watching twobrats smear food on the back window while Dad drifts into oncoming trafficat each corner.Now, I WOULD put some oil in there to avoid the corrosion issues mentionedin a previous post.----------John Coffeyjohncof@veriomail.com Link to comment https://www.classiczcars.com/forums/topic/123-strut-cartridge-replacement-dampening-oil/#findComment-283 Share on other sites More sharing options...
May 3, 200024 yr Author comment_284 -- Group Message from RICHARD SCHULZE <richard@eoa.com> --Dear Group:>-- Group Message from "Pete Paraska" <pparaska@tidalwave.net> -->I don't have handy any numbers on what the amount or rate of>conversion of this heat is for different driving conditions,>but it's not inconsequential.Pete hit the nail on the head! The energy generation from shocks is notinconsequential. As a Mechanic, I always put a little oil in the struthousing when replacing inserts. Now I find that many Auto manufacturersare designing and making Hybrid cars that are gas and electric. Theygain efficiency by recouping wasted energy. One of the prime waistsources is the cars kinetic energy which is converted into brake heatevery time you stop. On the hybrids, when you hit the brake pedal, agenerator is linked to the drive line which drags the car down whileproducing electricity to charge a battery pack. One of the biggestsecondary sources of wasted energy is shock absorber dampening. Themakers of Hybrids are designing shocks that are like linear motors whichget their dampening from electro magnetic repulsion while generatingelectricity for the batteries. There is a significant amount of energycoming from these shock and good heat dissipation will extend seal life.Richard Schulze--------------------------------------------------------------©The Internet 240z-Club - Our Web Site: http://www.240z.org Our Bulletin Board: http://www.240z.org/forums.htm Send your Email messages to: mailto:240z-club@peak.org-------------------------------------------------------------- Link to comment https://www.classiczcars.com/forums/topic/123-strut-cartridge-replacement-dampening-oil/#findComment-284 Share on other sites More sharing options...
December 28, 200123 yr comment_1611 I wanted to make sure this thread wasn't a one man show. Link to comment https://www.classiczcars.com/forums/topic/123-strut-cartridge-replacement-dampening-oil/#findComment-1611 Share on other sites More sharing options...
Create an account or sign in to comment