Anyone purchase these? If so, what is the quality compared to originals?

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=160682947792&fromMakeTrack=true&ssPageName=VIP:watchlink:top:en

Keith

Thanks, I just bought a set. Surprise me; postage was free.

What is the quality compared to originals?

When they arrive, I'll dig out my originals and write a full report!!!!With pictures!

To eliminate the steel-on-steel contact, why not just wrap the rod where the clip touches with clear tape?

26th-Z,

Did the clips arrive? If so, your observations about their quality is appreciated.

Keith

The clips arrived in the afternoon mail yesterday and I dug out my stash of clips to compare.

I have two sets of originals: one set from the car (with green overspray) and another new set I bought many years ago. I have been intrigued with the idea of making reproductions and I'm very happy to see people take on these sort of projects. The guy selling them on eBay sent me the set I ordered and another single clip made differently. The ones I bought are "hollow" and far more flexible than the solid version. The seller said he was concerned with how flexible the solid ones would be in cold weather.

I don't know what material was used or how they were made, but the repros are a material more opaque than the originals. The clip and mounting riser dimensions are the same as original however the 'wings' are shorter. Otherwise, they look real close to original, fit just fine, and clip in place with only slightly less force than original. I give them two thumbs up and recommend them.

They are very good quality and is made by a member in our club NYZCC. I compared them to the ones on #1905 before it was sold and like Chris stated they are very close to the original clips. They do make locking the inspection lid easier and take less force to "slam" shut.

If I were doing a resto job, I would want them. I know he also makes them in a few colors for the guys who want something a little different. If anyone is looking for very straight 69/early 70 lids email me. Clive.Bogle@gmail.com I have a set that needs to find a good home.

For what it's worth, I cleaned the paint off my old clips and while I was at it I performed the pinch-o-meter scale resistance test on each of the various clips I have to determine the level of pinch resistance each clip might have when it clamps the fender. For those of you not completely versed in the pinch-o-meter method of resistance testing, this is performed by engaging the test clip between thumb and forefinger whilst drinking a beer. Average ambient temperature of the clips should be 72 degrees F. Average resistance is determined over five squeezes. Comparative squeezing determines the bell curve in consideration of relativity.

My old original clips were the stiffest measuring a 7.5 average. The reproduction solid clip was almost as stiff measuring 7.3. Surprisingly, the NOS clips I have were noticably softer averaging a 5.1 and the reproduction hollow clips were not much softer than that, averaging a 5.0.

Edited November 24, 201113 yr by 26th-Z

Was this test done while listening to the "Dirty Curties Band"?

Bonzi Lon

Did some digging: Here is what I read:

http://www.classiczcars.com/forums/misc-s30/39035-inspection-lid-clips.html

http://www.classiczcars.com/forums/misc-s30/45969-series-1-inspection-lid-clips-another-attempt-reprinting.html

Does anyone have an update on these clips?  My 1/70 car needs them and I would like to buy 2 sets....