I'm assuming that as a working college student, time & money are a reasonably scarce. Because of this, I tend to agree with your Dad. A newer Civic, Corolla or a 3-to-5 year old Accord or Camry, Mazda 3, etc will be reliable enough to be a daily driver you can depend on, without having to spend a lot of money & time on maintenance. The problem with older, collectible cars is that unless you "restore" all the major systems to "as new", it will be less reliable than a modern car. This restoration will require you invest the about the same amount of money as a newer car, and lot's of your time. Otherwise, that old car will likely be less reliable and cost you more time & money to keep it running than a newer car. Also, for something like a 1970's 510 most parts won't be "on the shelf" at your local O'Rielly's Auto... I know that's probably not waht you wanted to hear...