Nope, I don't agree. maximum power is achieved with the proper fuel to air ratio. Richening the mixture will only result in more power if the mixture was too lean. There's many causes for that. Vacuum leak, float level too low, etc. Here's a shade tree mechanic's tip for determining if the mixture is too lean with SU's. At normal operating temperature, try gradually adding choke to the engine while going up a slight grade. If the mixture is too lean, you'll feel the burst of power.
I can't give you an opinion on the plug in the picture. It looks, to me, like an old carboned up plug that was kinda cleaned. The black uncleaned part looks like a rich mixture. The top white section and electrodes look extremely lean. What is the history of that plug? The porcelain should be a light brown (tan) color if the mixture is close.