If your plugs all look like that marshmellow, then you are losing mileage due to another reason. Dragging brakes, low tires, driveline drag, or a fuel leak. The little screw in the corner of the AFM is a BYPASS to allow air to go around the flap without getting metered. The more air you let sneak through that screw (counterclockwise), the leaner it idles. Just an FYI: If someone opened up the idle mixture screw in the AFM, all the way, it might idle lean. To compensate for that, someone may have erroneously turned the AFM tooth wheel to the rich side, making it idle perfectly. However, that would make it too rich everywhere else but idle. OTOH, toasty brown plugs would indicate that the combustion mixture was OK..so I refer you back to my first lines above. If I remember correctly, each tooth in the AFM represents about a 3% change in fuel mixture. PS. What kind of driving are you doing? A perfect Z can get 12mpg if driven hard. If it gets that on the highway at 55mph, then you have an issue.